Appeals

Appeals decisions

 

2019  
Date Description
18 June 2021 

Appeals lodged against the environmental authorisation granted for the proposed sea based aquaculture development zones in Algoa Bay, Gqeberha. within the Nelson Mandela Bay Metropolitan Municipality in the Eastern Cape Province. [PDF - 5.36 mb]

   

 

 

Appeals reports 

 

West coast rock lobster: reports in terms of Regulation 5(3) of the regulations promulgated unde the Marine Living Resources Act, 1998 (Act No. 18 of 1998): Appeal in terms of section 80 of the Marine Living Resources Act, 1998 (Act No. 18 of 1998):

  1. WCNF150327: West coast rock lobster nearshore fishery (Zone B), Andrew Petrus Johannes De Klerk [PDF - 305 kb]
  2. WCOM153480: West coast rock lobster offshore fishery, Bubesi Fishing (Pty) LTD [PDF - 2 mb]
  3. WCNB15573: West coast rock lobster nearshore fishery, Calvin Moses Van der Heever [PDF - 770.32 kb]
  4. WCOM153482: West coast rock lobster offshore fishery, Cape Reef Products (Pty) LTD  [PDF 2.17 mb]
  5. WCND151096: West coast rock lobster nearshore fishery (Zone B), Cecil Mzamo Mvayi [PDF - 630.17 kb]
  6. WCNF150716: West coast rock lobster nearshore fishery (Zone B), Chadwick Joel Gillion [PDF - 339 kb]
  7. WCND150112 West coast rock lobster nearshore fishery (Zone B), Deborah Magdalena Mary Thebus [PDF - 537 kb]
  8. WCNB15178: West coast rock lobster nearshore fishery (Zone B), Deidre Elvona van Wyk [PDF - 708.15 kb]
  9. WCNE150309: West coast rock lobster nearshore fishery (Zone E), Deon Bester [PDF - 323.54 kb]
  10. WCNF150982: West coast rock lobster nearshore fishery (Zone B), Desmond Clemont Brian Makka [PDF - 860.83 kb]
  11. WCNB15625: West coast rock lobster nearshore fishery (Zone B), Desmond Pedro Adams [PDF - 766.52 kb]
  12. WCNE150615: West Coast Rock Lobster Nearshore Fishery (Zone E), Spinach John Nkunzana [PDF - 1.03 mb]
  13. WCND151252: West coast rock lobster nearshore fishery (Zone B), Donovan Du Preez [94.35 kb]
  14. WCNF152332: West coast rock lobster nearshore fishery (Zone B), Dorethea Sarie November [593.49 kb]
  15. WCOM152163: West coast rock lobster offshore fishery, Dromedaris Vissery Ltd [135.66 kb]
  16. WCND151098: West coast rock lobster nearshore fishery (Zone B), Elcot Dyantyi [521.11 kb]
  17. WCNA15316: West coast rock lobster offshore fishery, Elias De Klerk
  18. WCNB15209: West coast rock lobster nearshore fishery (Zone B), Estelle Rachel Heyns [729. 92 kb]
  19. WCNF150545: West coast rock lobster nearshore fishery (Zone B), Gail Cornelius [309.74 kb]
  20. WCNE150668: West coast rock lobster nearshore fishery (Zone E), Galiema Baderoen [659.18 kb]
  21. WCNF151629: West coast rock lobster nearshore fishery (Zone B), Gavin Harold Pietersen [3374. 19 kb]
  22. WCNB15572: West coast rock lobster nearshore fishery (Zone B), Gert Saulus Simon [670. 27 kb]
  23. WCNF152492: West coast rock lobster nearshore fishery (Zone B), Gregory Pretorius [362.11 kb]
  24. WCNB15209: West coast rock lobster nearshore fishery (Zone B), Heidi lillian Pietersen [PDF - 1.24 MB]
  25. WCND150646: West coast rock lobster nearshore fishery (Zone B), Hendrik Boois [520.73 kb]
  26. West coast rock lobster nearshore fishery (Zone C), Hendrina van Hooi
  27. WCNB15209: West coast rock lobster offshore fishery, lnkosi Keta Marine (Pty) Ltd CC [PDF - 1.51 MB]
  28. WCNA15314: West coast rock lobster nearshore fishery, lsmael Hermanus Saal [794.01 kb]
  29. WCND150214: West coast rock lobster nearshore fishery (Zone B), Jabian Arries [516.85 kb]
  30. WCNA15439: West coast rock lobster, Jacqueline Leggett [554.69 kb]
  31. WCNE150682: West coast rock lobster nearshore fishery (Zone C), Jaliel Keyser [799.78 kb]
  32. WCND151185: West coast rock lobster nearshore fishery (Zone B), James Hendricks [679.64 kb]
  33. WCNB151016: West coast rock lobster nearshore fishery (Zone B), Jan Willem Dirks [676.55 kb]
  34. WCNF151336: West coast rock lobster nearshore fishery (Zone B), Jerome Curbon Figaji [318.13 kb]
  35. WCNE150601: West coast rock lobster nearshore fishery (Zone E), Johannes Lakey [710.11 kb]
  36. WCOM153484: West coast rock lobster offshore fishery, Karbonkelberg Marine CC [PDF - 2.08 MB]
  37. WCND150916: West coast rock lobster nearshore fishery (Zone B), Kevin Woodward [738.98 kb]
  38. WCOM153510: West coast rock lobster offshore fishery, Konsortium Kreefbelange (Pty) Ltd [PDF - 2.38 MB]

 

Exclusions: West coast rock lobster (offshore): reports in terms of Regulation 5(3) of the regulations promulgated unde the Marine Living Resources Act, 1998 (Act No. 18 of 1998): Appeal in terms of section 80 of the Marine Living Resources Act, 1998 (Act No. 18 of 1998):

  1. West coast rock lobster offshore appeals excluded for being co-operatives [PDF - 143.83 kb]
  2. West coast rock lobster offshore appeals excluded for non-disclosure of MLRA violations [PDF - 253.35 kb]
  3. West coast rock lobster offshore appeals excluded category A applicants for scoring below 60% threshold [PDF - 265.02 kb]
  4. West coast rock lobster offshore appeals excluded category B applicants as the category is not allowed in the west coast rock lobster offshore fishery [PDF - 
  5. West coast rock lobster offshore appeals excluded category C applicants for scoring below 50% threshold [PDF - 502.60 kb] 
  6. West coast rock lobster offshore appeals excluded: paper quota risk appicants [PDF - 210.94 kb]
  7. West coast rock lobster offshore appeals excluded for failure to sign / commission the application forms [PDF - 185.04 kb]
  8. West coast rock lobster offshore appeals excluded for submitting materially defective applications in that they provided false information [PDF - 132.35 kb]

 

West coast rock lobster (nearshore)

  1. WCNB15472 Wilfred James Dampies: fishing performance and transformation [PDF - 123 kb]

 

West coast rock lobster zone A appeals

  1. Delegated authority’s decision not to allow applicants older than 65 years of age to become successful applicants [PDF - 185 kb]
  2. Delegated authority’s decision not to allow applicants who are mediacally unfit to become successful applicants [PDF - 185 kb]
  3. Delegated authority’s decision not to allow category B and C new entrants to become successful applicants [PDF - 293 kb]

 

West coast rock lobster zone B appeals

  1. West coast rock lobster offshore appeals excluded for failure to sign their 2015/16 application form for fishing rights ("application form") and the failure of one (1) appellant to both sign and commission her application form [PDF 181 kb]
  2. Delegated authority’s decision not to allow applicants older than 65 years of age to become successful applicants [PDF 213 kb]
  3. Delegated authority’s decision not to allow applicants who are mediacally unfit to become successful applicants [PDF 651 kb]
  4. Delegated authority’s decision not to allow category B and C new entrants to become successful applicants [PDF 861 kb]
  5. West coast rock lobster zone B appeals excluded for non-disclosure of MLRA violations [PDF 261 kb]

 

West coast rock lobster zone C appeals

  1. West coast rock lobster offshore appeals excluded for failure to sign their 2015/16 application form for fishing rights ("application form") and the failure of one (1) appellant to both sign and commission her application form [PDF 178 kb]
  2. Delegated authority’s decision not to allow applicants older than 65 years of age to become successful applicants [PDF 238 kb]
  3. Delegated authority’s decision not to allow applicants who are mediacally unfit to become successful applicants [PDF 317 kb]
  4. Delegated authority’s decision not to allow category B and C new entrants to become successful applicants [PDF 434 kb]
  5. West coast rock lobster zone C appeals excluded for non-disclosure of MLRA violations [PDF 177 kb]

 

West coast rock lobster zone D appeals

  1. West coast rock lobster offshore appeals excluded for failure to sign their 2015/16 application form for fishing rights ("application form") and the failure of one (1) appellant to both sign and commission her application form [PDF 191 kb]
  2. Delegated authority’s decision not to allow category B and C new entrants to become successful applicants [PDF 2 716 kb]
  3. West coast rock lobster zone D appeals excluded for non-disclosure of MLRA violations [PDF 174 kb]

 

West coast rock lobster zone E appeals

  1. West coast rock lobster offshore appeals excluded for failure to sign their 2015/16 application form for fishing rights ("application form") and the failure of one (1) appellant to both sign and commission her application form [PDF 186 kb]
  2. Delegated authority’s decision not to allow applicants older than 65 years of age to become successful applicants [PDF 186 kb]
  3. Delegated authority’s decision not to allow category E and C new entrants to become successful applicants [PDF 395 kb]

 

West coast rock lobster zone F appeals

  1. West coast rock lobster offshore appeals excluded for failure to sign their 2015/16 application form for fishing rights ("application form") and the failure of one (1) appellant to both sign and commission her application form [PDF 565 kb]
  2. Delegated authority’s decision not to allow applicants older than 65 years of age to become successful applicants [PDF 2 278 kb]
  3. Delegated authority’s decision not to allow category B and C new entrants to become successful applicants [PDF 1 822 kb]
  4. West coast rock lobster zone B appeals excluded for non-disclosure of MLRA violations [PDF 581 kb]

 

West coast rock lobster zone G

  1. WCNF150023 Zukiswa Ellen Mqhokrwana: accessibility of suitable fishing vessel and fishing performance grounds of appeal [PDF 387 kb]

 

Demersal shark sector: reports in terms of Regulation 5(3) of the regulations promulgated under the Marine Living Resources Act, 1998 (Act No. 18 of 1998): Appeal in terms of section 80 of the Marine Living Resources Act, 1998 (Act No. 18 of 1998):

  1. DMS130145: G&K Fisheries CC [PDF - 877 kb]
  2. DMS 130147: Dragon Fish Fisherman CC [PDF - 383.16 kb]
  3. DMS 130184: JNC Fishing (Pty) LTD [PDF - 359.59 kb]
  4. DMS 130185: Hacky Fishing  (Pty) LTD [PDF - 996.44 kb]
  5. DMS 130219: Cape Town Harbour Fisherman’s Community Trust [PDF - 486.4 kb]
  6. DMS 130228: Overberg Commercial Abalone Divers LTD [PDF - 473.88 kb]
  7. DMS 130243: Villet Dewet 100 CC [PDF - 366.42 kb]
  8. DMS 130322: Khoi Groep 13 Services Co-operative [PDF - 496 kb]
  9. DMS 130349: Yellow Star Trading 1154 (Pty) LTD [PDF - 405 kb]
  10. DMS 130359: BEVCON General Trading (Pty) LTD [PDF - 368.69 kb]
  11. DMS 130360: New Horizon Primary Fishing [PDF - 435.47 kb]
  12. DMS 130457: GOAPRO (Pty) LTD [PDF - 365.59 kb]
  13. DMS 130569: Ulwandle Fishing (Pty) LTD [PDF - 829.17 kb]
  14. DMS 130574: Mbotho Fishing [PDF - 380.08 kb]
  15. DMS 130590: FINECORP Trading 113 (Pty) LTD [PDF - 274.9 kb]
  16. DMS 130605: Ubuhle Bezwe Holdings (Pty) LTD [PDF - 380.82 kb]
  17. DMS 130737: Collin Govender [PDF - 417.05 kb]
  18. DMS 130806: Tshatshu Seafood Industry [PDF - 400.07 kb]
  19. DMS 130809: Mnyama Women Commerical Fishing Enterprise (Pty) LTD [PDF - 389.09 kb]
  20. DMS 130901: Coalition Trading 672 CC [PDF - 383.87
  21. DMS 130916: Trade Factor 16 (Pty) LTD [PDF - 424.14 kb]

 

White mussels

  1. White mussel appeals lodged by appellants domiciled within the City of Cape Town: appeal rejected because it is too weak to justify [PDF - 288.09 kb]
  2. White mussel appeals lodged by appellants domiciled outside the jurisdiction of the west coast and the City of Cape Town: appeal rejected because it is too weak to justify [PDF - 401.79]
  3. White mussel appeals lodged by appellants domiciled along the west coast harvesting zones 2,3,4,5,6, and 7: appeal rejected because it is too weak to justify [PDF - 413.09 kb]